Whether you’re into them or not, age gap romances continue to captivate readers. Depending on the story and genre, it could be the forbidden allure aspect that fascinates the audience, or it could be the complexity of the relationship itself. But that’s the thing: genre makes a difference.

Age gap romances in contemporary literature explore social norms and power dynamics.

Oftentimes, contemporary stories navigate the complexities of societal judgment, power differentials, and personal insecurities that come with large age gaps. Whether it’s a young ingenue falling for an older, experienced mentor or a mature protagonist finding unexpected passion with a younger partner, these narratives challenge conventional notions of romance and highlight the universality of human connection.

These stories often lean on the controversial nature of the relationship. They’re meant to be a little uncomfortable. But for that reason, their reception is often critical.

Age gaps in fantasy romances explore mortality and eternity.

In otherworldly realms, age gaps take on a whole new dimension, as immortal beings traverse centuries, if not millennia, of existence. While contemporary romances may grapple with society, paranormal and fantasy romances delve into existential questions of identity, mortality, and the nature of love itself.

Characters in these otherworldly tales often face challenges beyond the scope of human comprehension, adding layers of intrigue and mystique to their relationships. Moreover, these portrayals can lend themselves to the more dramatic themes of eternal love, redemption, and the power of connection across lifetimes.

So, basically, age gaps in fantasy are easier to both romanticize and dramatize compared to contemporary literature. Which makes them entertaining and perfect for escapism. I feel this is why a 20 year age gap is viewed as icky, but a 500 year age gap is viewed as sexy.

Also, this is just speculation, but maybe there’s something to be said about readers enjoying a centuries-old love interest that looks about 25. Perhaps it’s the appeal of them being both emotionally mature and young? Food for thought.

Age gap romances in general are not without critique.

Regardless of genre or author intentions, the power imbalances are often the biggest point of contention. In many cases, the older partner holds more authority, experience, and resources, which can create unequal dynamics and raise questions about consent and agency. Particularly when the younger partner is depicted as vulnerable or impressionable.

Let’s not forget the potential for reinforcing stereotypes. Some contemporary age gap romances rely on stereotypical tropes and clichés, such as the “older man rescuing the younger woman” or the “naïve ingenue being swept off her feet by a worldly older partner.” These tropes can reinforce traditional gender roles and fail to provide nuanced portrayals of age gap relationships.

Critics also argue that many age gap romances romanticize or idealize the dynamics of such relationships, downplaying or even ignoring the real challenges they entail. Some have pointed out that impressionable readers may come away from the story wanting a similar romance in real life, not noticing potential toxicity.

They’re not for everyone, but neither should they be written off.

Age gap romance books offer a diverse array of narratives that explore the complexities of love across generations and realms. Whether it’s a serious work that aims at asking controversial questions or just a silly fun romance for escapism, they all have a place for readers.