Spoiler-Free Review

If you liked Weyward by Emilia Hart, then I think you’ll like The Once and Future Witches, too.

Click here for content warnings.

What’s The Once and Future Witches about?

In 1893, three estranged sisters are inexplicably drawn together again in a fight for suffrage that becomes a hunt to bring back witchcraft.

I liked it, but not as much as I thought I would.

The writing for this book was immaculate. No joke, it was beautifully written and the settings were visceral; Harrow really engaged all the senses with her descriptions. Whether it was the texture of spice in the air of a shop, or the humid dread of a sweatshop, or the slow-southern drawl of the narration, it all felt so real. And it feels strange to give a 3-star rating to a book with such a distinct voice and way with words.

It’s just that, despite this beautiful prose, I found myself not wanting to reach for this book when I sat down to read. I think it’s because of a slowness, and perhaps a bit of predictability, on the part of the plot – and neither are necessarily inherent drawbacks. I think this really can be chalked up to reader’s preference, and for that reason I’m still going to recommend it, but with an asterisks that it’s going to depend on your mood.

Beyond that, the characterizations of each of the sisters were both compelling and interesting. They were unalike in almost every way, and yet, these differences complemented each other. As a reader, you feel the love and frustrations that make up the complicated relationships between those who see the best and worst of each other.

Should you read The Once and Future Witches?

If you’re looking for a masterclass in prose, especially prose that places you firmly in the story, read this book. I also recommend it to fans of long, character-driven novels which have plots but are not necessarily about the plot.

Also, if strong character profiles and stories about sisterhood are compelling to you, this should definitely be on your list. Bonus points for witchcraft (and witch hunts), feminine rage, and women’s suffrage.

It may not be for you if you prefer plot-driven stories or tighter narratives.